
It had been a while since I tried using a
Koh-I-Noor Rapidograph Pen. Got this 0.25 mm pen on sale recently and decided to test it using the Staedtler Mars Professional technical pen with disposable refill cartridges as a benchmark. While I normally prefer pen caps that snap on and off the pen body, both technical pens feature threaded caps that can be posted on the back of the pen barrels while in-use. With its maintenance-free design, the Staedtler pen has the advantage as the more user-friendly product since it can be refilled by simply swapping the ink cartridges (each refill change brings a brand new pen nib with its own fresh ink reservoir). The refillable Rapidograph pen requires regular time-consuming and potentially-messy cleanings of the pen nib assembly to remain in good working order.
The needle-like metal tube nib of the
Rapidograph pen feels scratchier on the gridded index card and
Moleskine sketchbook paper compared to the plastic nib encased in a metal jacket of the
Staedtler technical pen which glides super smoothly on the same supports.

Close up of these technical pens' nibs. While both 0.25 mm pen nibs lay down fine lines of very similar thickness (with the
Rapidograph pen making slightly thinner lines), the
Staedtler pen nib looks a bit wider and feels stronger while drawing over a wider range of drawing angles. The
Rapidograph pen nib feels rather delicate and tends to skip when holding the pen at sharper angles to the paper. Its performance is very similar to that of the the
Koh-I-Noor Rapidosketch pen.

The ink of both pens is waterproof once dried, so the sketches can be easily colored with wet media like watercolor pencils and a waterbrush without smearing the inked outlines.
8 comments:
I recently came accross your blog and have been reading along. I thought I would leave my first comment. I dont know what to say except that I have enjoyed reading. Nice blog. I will keep visiting this blog very often.
Susan
http://sketchingdrawing.com
Thanks for stopping by and making a comment.
Thanks, I am trying to decide what kind of drawing pen I am going to get, now I know, the mars Professional, thanks for posting this.
Thank's for this technical pen comparison. I have an old Rapidograph from a previous career. It's great to learn about the easier to clean and smoother Staedtler pen. Looks like it would be more expensive over time because of the refill costs?
The old refillable technical pens provide great service, but tend to require great care and maintenance. They certainly would seem the more economical approach for heavy users, but the disposable refills approach also has its merits. One gets a nice fresh nib with each refill change. The plastic composite nibs encased in a metal sleeve design usually glide effortlessly and also feel smoother on most papers than the metal cylinder nibs of older technical pens. Keep an eye out for sales and clearance bins in
Office Supplies stores for the refills can often be had at a discount.
Honestly, when I read that you used a stainless steel Rapidograph tip on sketch paper, I wanted to screech, "Don't do it!" Rapidograph is definitely more for the heavy, pro-user while Steadtler doesn't quite have the draftsman-like perfect consistency of the Rapidograph. But using on sketch paper will collect fuzz in any pro-grade technical pen and clog it, so be careful! Make sure to use it on smooth pro-grade bristol or some other compatible board. Paper makes a HUGE difference. You can't just go clogging your nice pens with crappy paper. Remember that Rapidographs are "drafting/engineering" pens made for board and film, NOT everyday sketchbook sketching. Of COURSE it will scratch and skip on such incompatible paper; you might even ruin your pen!
Rapidographs really aren't hard to clean at all if you know what you're doing. I find that instead of taking it apart completely, it's better to just soak the tip in the Rapidoeeze ever 1-2 weeks and you're good to go. Keep it upright, tip-side up in a humid place and you won't get any problems. Even pens that have dried ink can generally be saved with some cleaner, a few good soaks, and a pen starter. The only real danger with a rapidograph is clumsy mishandling that damages the tip (and of course loggin it with incompatible paper).
DEFINITELY prefer ink fills to cartridge pens in the long haul if you're a heavy pen user, while an amateur/light user may benefit from disposable or cartridge, I think.
Thank you very much for the thorough comment and the advice on how to properly use and care for stainless steel nib technical pens. Will certainly keep it in mind, when doing any further testing with my vintage technical pen collection.
Post a Comment