Friday, April 3, 2009

Couple of disappointments in my last batch of "Art Supplies"

Finally completed my collection triad of Japanese supreme wooden pencils (Tombow Mono 100, Mitsubishi Hi-Uni, and the Pentel Polymer 999) with the arrival of a dozen Pentel Polymer 999 HB pencils in my last JetPens order. While I'm glad to have had the opportunity to add this pencil to my collection, I am not particularly impressed by its performance fresh out of the box which is in itself a pretty nice example of cardboard packaging seldom seen in the stationery aisles anymore. This pencil is shipped unsharpened and is fairly rare in the US market with its elegant matte black finish and silver cap accents. Started removing the bulk of the exterior wood layers with a Panasonic(R) KP-310 Electric Pencil Sharpener, and then tried to finish sharpening it with a new General's All Art colored pencil sharpener. Yet the graphite core offered great resistance against the cutting blade edge and cracking at the tip. It did not sharpen easily even with a fairly new Prismacolor sharpener (graphite point still split and cracked even while holding the sharpener vertically to reduce stress) and it drew ok but nothing spectacular. To be fair, the slogan on the box reads "the highest quality for general use" which probably means mostly writing applications. Thus they are not making any claims of being second-to-none art tools since their true top grade offering is the virtually impossible to find Pentel Black Polymer 999α. Maybe I am being too picky, already biased by the awesomeness of the Hi-Uni, and this was not by any means a structured blind test.
Did a couple of quick test doodles, and the Polymer 999 did show to be a tad darker than the same grade in the Hi-Uni range. Its lead feel on the same paper was nowhere near as smooth as the Mitsubishi Hi-Uni or the Tombow Mono 100 though.

Sorry to report that I find this pencil to be nothing special, and that most users (other than the most dedicated pencil collector) would be better served by ignoring this wooden pencil offering and just go for the best choice in existence: the legendary Mitsubishi Uni-ball Hi-Uni.



I had waited a long time to try this Kuretake Disposable Medium Pocket Brush Sign Pen since I already have several working brush pens that are quite reliable like the Premier Archival markers and the Faber Castell Pitt Artist pens. I had hoped this pen's substantial nib size would have made it a suitable tool for quick sketching of large scale cartoons and caricatures, but unfortunately the nib ink flow is so slow that yields only pale and streaking lines when attempting to draw longer strokes.

Fresh out of its sealed package, this brush pen's initial test marks showed heavy streaking or a "dry brush" effect as if the pen was already partially dried when drawing at normal speeds.
Very busy gold lettering covers one side of the pen's barrel. Not a particularly attractive design since all that text makes it look rather cluttered. I even left the capped pen pointing down on a pencil cup for a few minutes to see if gravity would speed up the ink flow, but it did not seem to have any effect.
Even when considerably slowing down my usual drawing speed, the pen started to streak just after a couple of dark strokes (notice the white streaking in the wavy lines inside the bird body outline). When going very slowly, it is possible to achieve uniform dark lines with it. Thus it would probably be an adequate tool for calligraphy and careful rendering of Kanji. I would not recommend this pen for sketching and drawing though. While both these tools may have failed my arbitrary standards for quality sketching tools, they may very well be perfectly fine for their intended purpose of general writing and Eastern calligraphy.

6 comments:

mabeloos said...

oh boo. i just placed an order for the polymer 999 in 3B. too bad about the performance, since the matte black casing is such a nice, understated look. i do love my hi-uni pencils, though -- so buttery smooth. thanks for the review!

Gentian said...

Sorry to hear they were both disappointing, especially when you are looking forward to getting them. I have the Kuretake double sided brush sign pen in that line and it works great. I really like it. It is too bad the regular sign pen seems to give trouble.

B2-kun said...

I suspect the 3B would have to be smoother than the HB I got, so your experience would probably be a tad more positive. Yet I wouldn't expect them to be as buttery smooth as the Hi-Uni's. Sorry I didn't post this sooner and spare you any potential disappointment.

mabeloos said...

not at all. your reviews have been more than helpful in my purchasing decisions. =) and the 3B could be used for rough sketching, doodling, and writing at work (i still need pencils in the office, and we are sorely lacking in supplies). and sketching with the nieces and nephew, of course.

Anonymous said...

Hi Alberto, I'm sorry to hear of your disappointment over the Pentel Black Polymer 999 HB's. Perhaps the one you sharpened was an uncharacteristically bad one?

I have this pencil in 2B and used it on Spectrum Multi-Use copier paper doing puzzles last night. I have to say I was quite impressed with its overall performance. Of course I wasn't using it to draw with, but in 2B I found it to be a dark and smooth writer. My sense of it is that it doesn't wear as slowly as the equivalent grade of Hi-Uni but its point is more durable than the Palomino 2B. Elsewhere you have written the Palomino is the darkest 2B available and I quite agree, but boy it wears fast. If the Pentel doesn't quite reach the pinnacle of top rank drawing pencils, it is a first rate writing implement (which you allow).

I'm also quite taken with its matte black exterior but not as impressed as Stephen with its silver accents. On mine the silver lettering is indistinct, nowhere near the crisp execution of the beautiful gold writing on the Hi-Unis. The Pentel's silver markings almost look like dot-matrix printing which I find something of a letdown in such an otherwise cool looking pencil. With the Hi-Uni's the closer you look at them the more impressed you become with their workmanship. Very few other pencils pass this test. So I can't disagree that the Mitsu-bishi Hi-Uni's are still the ones to go after, but I don't think mabeloos will be too crestfallen at what she gets in her Pentels. I have really enjoyed your take on your triad of Japanese supreme wooden pencils and look forward to more.

Barrel Of A Pencil

B2-kun said...

Thanks Barrel. I was not too terribly disappointed with the Pentel 999. It is more like it failed to wow me. I might give my HB lot a second chance on other papers and see how well they perform.
But in the meantime, The Hi-Uni pencils reign supreme among the rest and continue to hold the unchallenged position of "Best pencil in the World!"